Sandwiches, first and foremost. This isn’t a dense, crusty deli rye. It’s a soft sandwich loaf, so it’s easy to bite into and holds up to a stacked Reuben, turkey and Swiss, or leftover roast beef. It also makes great toast with butter. It has no preservatives, so it goes stale faster than store-bought. Freeze what you won’t eat in the first few days.
You get all the flavor of rye from rye flour, caraway seeds, and dill seeds. You don’t get the sharp, twangy bite, because Phil leaves out the pickle juice. It’s a rye even the people who “don’t like rye” might come around on. It’s simple, small-batch baking with nothing you can’t pronounce.
Keep at room temperature for 3–4 days, or freeze sliced for up to 3 months. Thaw slices as needed.